Reviews

Great food! Great atmosphere! Great waiter/witresses. Always helful. So much food we had to take half home for the next day! Great place all around (was there between lunch & dinner so it wasn't crazy busy. They accomidated 2 handicapped people in wheelchairs as well AAA+ IN MY BOOK!
Sonja G via google.com - Apr 24, 2018
Awesome Shepard's pie...note that there's PLENTY to share between two people and you'll still have trouble finishing it.
Ryan Donovan via google.com - Apr 20, 2018
Wow! This place was such a shock! We had always seen it stuck in the corner of the mall but just never thought to try it. One night we did and we are so happy! The portions are huge! We didn't try the pizza but we saw a table with one and it looked fantastic! We had the Guinness Beef Pie and the Chicken Pot Pie and both were very goo ... read more
Samantha Pacella via google.com - Apr 5, 2018
Dinners are getting better than ever!
Been coming here for years- every Wednesday night. Menu has been getting much better (think chef from the other Muldoon's that closed is now here full time). Granted it was Valentines day this week, but the dinner menu had: Tortellini, Tomahawk Steak for two, Prime...More ... read more
Eugenepw via tripadvisor.com - Feb 16, 2018
I have never had a bad meal or service here. From the Irish food to the gyro... delicious!!
Kimberly Osborne via google.com - Feb 14, 2018
Delicious food, Coleen is impressive!
Blaze Algiere via google.com - Feb 14, 2018
Ok. Nice cocktails ... read more
Dave Sullivan via google.com - Feb 14, 2018
Great spot for sit down food in the mall.
Shepherds pie was fantastic and huge! Well seasoned and flavorful. Fish and chips were very tasty too. Pizza was fresh and delicious. Specially made chicken salad over greens was also very pleasing. Will definitely return and hopefully have Kevin again as our entertaining and attentive...More ... read more
Yukon2017 via tripadvisor.com - Oct 21, 2017
Always great food and service!
Kym Alders via google.com - Oct 14, 2017
Dinner
Great place to eat and have a drink, we had a great waiter that was always willing to start a conversation. Will definitely go back again.
james827martin via tripadvisor.com - Sep 14, 2017
Have the fish and chips and a Guinness. The closer you get to authentic Irish food the better it is here. French onion soup is bangin too.
Steven MichaelBristol via google.com - Sep 14, 2017
Hearty meal. Spacious, wooden furnishings, friendly staff.
Sean Gugler via google.com - Sep 14, 2017
Very good food and table service.
Loci Lenar via google.com - Sep 14, 2017
Friendly get together
You really need to get there early if she'll jump quickly. The food is excellent, the drinks are always made to perfection. But it gets crowded early ... read more
Deacon Vince via tripadvisor.com - Sep 6, 2017
The tuna steak salad was very good. The server was pleasant. ... read more
roger Thomas via google.com - Aug 14, 2017
Really good - not a "mall eatery"
a little tough to find - lower level near Macy's. 4 of us each had a very good dinner. Steak salad with fresh mozzarella - tasty and tender; grilled veggie sandwich - juicy & flavorful, burger was done as asked ... read more
Tom_B_NJ via tripadvisor.com - Jul 28, 2017
Very good, quick service ... read more
Ernie Bush via google.com - Jul 14, 2017
Good pub food ... read more
a mcguire via google.com - Jul 14, 2017
Excellent ahi tuna salad and Shepard pie.
Alan Rappaport via google.com - Jun 14, 2017
Never crowed and a French dip to die for!!!
Len Azzarone via google.com - Jun 14, 2017
Great food, good service, love the trivia.
Paul Sandefur via google.com - Jun 14, 2017
Great place to eat the food is amazing ... read more
Sharon Klingener via google.com - May 14, 2017
Great food and drinks
Love this place. Employees are great and friendly. Good is great. Right in the Rockaway Mall. So plenty of parking.
Veronica T via tripadvisor.com - May 13, 2017
Nice for in a Macy's
I went with a girlfriend while shopping. Atmosphere was nice and the waitress was friendly. Food was average, nothing special, but delicious. Needs more wait staff, as I only saw two servers and the place was filling up fast while we were there. 2 appetizers,...More ... read more
Sunshine P via tripadvisor.com - Apr 21, 2017
The food was very good and the portions too. The place is too loud to hear yourself hold a conversation. They need more TVs in the back area. Our waiter was awesome too. Didn't like that you had to use the bathrooms in Macys!
Jamie Smith via google.com - Apr 14, 2017
Muldoons is a great gem buried in Macy's at the Rockaway mall. Because it does not have a proper storefront, hungry shoppers often forget about it, leaving it quiet. Service is generally fast. There are reasonably priced beers on tap and a wide variety of sandwiches and burgers for those not looking to break the bank or split their p ... read more
Abby Benjamin via google.com - Mar 14, 2017
My wife and I really enjoy this restaurant. If it's your first time there you might have a hard time finding it because of its very strange location at the back of Macy's on the lower level. It's easier to access from the outside parking lot. The food is consistently good, and they have a good beer menu. The staff are veterans and al ... read more
Joshua Weinstein via google.com - Mar 14, 2017
Good food ... read more
gene rossi via google.com - Mar 14, 2017
The pot roast was very tasty and tender. Felt like am authentic Irish pub.
Rob Johnson via google.com - Mar 14, 2017
Excellent restaurant with excellent food and service couldn't ask for a better place to eat lunch and dinner. Prices are reasonable and worth every penny. Have eaten there many times for many years. My husband and I love this place ... read more
Karin Porras via google.com - Mar 14, 2017
Not a bad place I find it funny where it is located. Food is good and beers are cold. Service is pretty good too.
martin feuer via google.com - Mar 14, 2017
Service is always fantastic! Very friendly... Food comes out quick. Try the chicken romano sandwich!
Kevin Kratochvil via google.com - Mar 14, 2017
Nice Irish themed restaurant. Good for after work visit. Plenty of parking. ... read more
Louis Cyphere via google.com - Mar 14, 2017
Fast Service
The food is really good and the service is great. The prices are inexpensive and will fit your budget.
clentz2017 via tripadvisor.com - Feb 16, 2017
Best Corned Beef and Friendly Staff
Irish Theme Pub with favorites like Shepard's Pie and Bangers and Mash. The Corned Beef is the best I have found in this area. Have it in a Reuben or on top of the Irish Burger. Friendly staff makes the trip worth finding this hidden...More ... read more
Sandy S via tripadvisor.com - Dec 1, 2016
Great place!
The food is good. The wait staff is great. You start to feel like family after a few visits. Awesome corned beef and cabbage.
g74cs via tripadvisor.com - Apr 25, 2016
Awesome ribs!
I have been here plenty of times. Each time I go I always order the full rack of ribs. They are amazing. Plenty of meat and it always falls off. Plus its a whole rack and they give you one side so you can split...More ... read more
Brie V via tripadvisor.com - Apr 4, 2016
Great Irish Pub atmosphere. $29.99 two for one with a bottle of wine is unbeatable and the food is excellent!
James Politan via google.com - Mar 14, 2016
Nice selection! ... read more
nic p via google.com - Mar 14, 2016
For a change!
Love this restaurant for the atmosphere and the different choices you can have there. It is comfortable enough to bring children and the food is really very well done!!!
Nytrane via tripadvisor.com - Dec 10, 2015
Just a good bar food joint.
Stopped I with my mom and sister for some late lunch. Ordered appetizers to share which were just ok. Service was pleasant but accidentally put the wrong order in. No worse for the wear. It's quieter than most places in the mall.
Crookedwillow via tripadvisor.com - Aug 18, 2015
Good for quick bite
We dined here for a quick bite - my wife's Turkey Club was very good with side salad substitute for fried. My Cheesesteak was huge well served with peppers, onions & mushrooms on-top - fries very tasty. For a Thursday around 7:30pm had a nice...More ... read more
Thomas D via tripadvisor.com - Jul 18, 2015
great place for lunch
This is one of my favorite places to eat when I am in Rockaway Mall. My favorite is the steak sandwich with the french fries. The fries are always golden brown and nice and crispy. yummm...Never got a bad meal there...
caroljhallman via tripadvisor.com - Mar 25, 2015
Burger was out of this world!
I had the Irish Burger, I think it's on the menu all the time, it had corn beef and swiss cheese on top of a beef burger. Bun was just ok...but who needs it, the burger cut with a fork and knife was divine!! Fries...More ... read more
June R via tripadvisor.com - Mar 17, 2015
Yes one of the best meals i have been eaten.
Nice place visited twice. Meals far from expectations . Great ! no, Excellent! yes that is the word for it. Yankee pot roast , Shepard's pie.. you name it. It is however inside a mall.
FisherManGreg via tripadvisor.com - Mar 9, 2015
The best ribs ever....
Great bar and grill, Great atmosphere, while not a BBQ joint the ribs we had were tender and fantastic!!!!
BGarbus via tripadvisor.com - Oct 17, 2014
Great dinner value and place to meet with friends
Nice atmosphere, great meal package available--dinner for 2 with a bottle of wine for $29.99 with reasonable upgrade menus and wines available. Went during a weeknight and it was not crowded so we were able to sit and talk for a few hours over a...More ... read more
Janet B via tripadvisor.com - Aug 15, 2014
Fits the bill
When shopping at the mall, your dining options are limited. There are a few chain places in the vicinity, and they all share the same, annoying characteristics;overcrowded, overpriced, and void of any atmosphere whatsoever. Muldoon's, however, is not like that. You do get the feeling...More ... read more
jlav46691 via tripadvisor.com - Jul 3, 2014
What a pleasant place!
I had passed it right up so many times on my way into the mall, but decided to stop the other day for lunch. The staff is very cordial and welcoming. It made me feel right at home. I enjoyed a grilled vegetable sandwich which...More ... read more
enseno via tripadvisor.com - Feb 23, 2014
Excellent Food, a bit pricey
Went for Dinner tonight with my family. Dinners are a bit pricey (soup/salad extra) but sandwiches/burgers are fairly priced. Food was very good. My table had the mild wings for an app, Ruben sandwich (5 stars), rigatoni vodka (Italian rest. quality) and Bangers & mash...More ... read more
Adam E via tripadvisor.com - Feb 19, 2014
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
Google+FoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip Advisor